Here's the first time I've ever used it on my cowboy boots. It seems to validate my current maintenance routine, I think, which is generally Bick 4 for dedicated conditioning and VSC as more of a hybrid conditioner/polish. The results from my first short term conditioner test were interesting to me, but raised obvious questions about how conditioner would affect leather that was actually in need of conditioning. I put to the test with my old pair of Alden Indys. Some very common examples found in many handsoaps and shampoos would be sodium dodecyl sulfate and sodium lauryl sulfate. I live in the desert so things can get very dry during the summer. Chamberlain is mostly wax and very little oil. I have, use and love Bick 4, Reno and VSC, though they're used in somewhat over-lapping ways. Bickmore Bick 4 Leather Conditioner is specially formulated to condition, clean, polish, and preserve all smooth finished leather. it leaves a thick film on the shoes which I imagine is the bees wax and other oils that remain to condition. Bottle. All in all according to people I know the testing could have gone worse, by which she meany “longer.” I liberally applied each conditioner to the leather sets and then let them sit for three weeks. Press J to jump to the feed. It could be that whatever the emulsifying agent is in Lexol binds water and it’s hard to boil off at low temps. I will recommend this conditioner to everyone I hate. Washes away with soap and water. Thanks u/Varnu for your effots!! Buy It Now +C $24.71 shipping estimate. But thanks for doing this and posting your results! I’ll keep VSC in my cabinet and might use Chamberlain on leather furniture in the future. And thank you :) glad to know those are reliable conditioners. Major summary first: Some conditioners darken way more than others. Bickmore Bick 4 Leather Conditioner 8 oz - Best Since 1882 - Cleaner & Conditioner - Restore Polish & Protect All Smooth Finished Leathers 4.6 out of 5 stars 2,174 $9.79 $ 9 . I have searched the site and the following products have been mentioned: Lexol Leather Conditioner Picard Leather Dressing Bickmore Bick 4 Brooks Proofride Has anyone tried more than one of … Good, I imagine, for imparting a shine. (And that conditioning should be done here and there, and cleaning should be done rarely), So, basically; Why do these products claim to be both? I find saphir to have more of these oils I would imagine to make up for whatever Reno may have over cleaned. Leather Honey is some sort of mystery fluid that isn’t an oil. I think that is what Bick 4 is doing - claiming the natural additional effects of its conditioner. It smells the same but costs half as much. New product releases, daily discussion and community building with a common interest in quality footwear. Check Price Bottom Line . Thanks for the amount of work you've done in creating these experiments. I can move it there if you like! I feel like something that gave me good perspective is reading up on something called "the oil cleansing method". Saphir’s Balm is a special leather conditioner for high end specialty leathers. I agree with some of the other comments here about the sulfated oils being a okay idea for leather car seats, but less so for leather exposed to wet conditions. Personally, Bick 4 is my favorite when I want a straight conditioner. Sometimes patina CONSISTS of scratches and scuffs. Sounds like this went over about as well as the science projects I do in my house (perhaps better since I tend to get far more sarcastic comments). Your Wife's comments had me dying btw lmao. Is the balm the same as cream, just packed in a different bottle? Do you want to make them look new again? Leather looks like new again after just one application. ... hide until it achieves the desired softness. C $29.20. This is a review by a master leather craftsman that has used Bick 4 on all sorts of leather for years. Didn't melt away when exposed to hot water. It’s helpful to have a better informed second opinion. That is where products like Renovateur separates from VSC for me, due to the turpentine component - It makes it a cleaning/conditioning dual product where Reno is more of a "conditioner with benefits." New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the goodyearwelt community. Not sure which one is right. Fairly new to this sub. Mink oil soaks in very fast. Facebook 0 Twitter LinkedIn 0 Reddit Tumblr Pinterest 0. I also see a lot of people talking about Smith's leather balm lately. And any other information you can add would be great! On the auto side of things, polish/wax combinations are invariably bad waxes that (A) don't last very long and (B) contain stuff that makes getting a truly good result the traditional way later pretty tough (usually silicone). It is ideal for all smooth leathers and is recommended for exotic skins. Both mink and lanolin caused not just darkening, but blotchy darkening, which is worse. It doesn’t claim to be a conditioner, it’s a dressing, but I don’t know what I might need to dress with it. Very helpful. I have seven more strips of old leather and I’m repeating the cracking prevention test with Obenauf’s, Lexol, Saphir, Esquire, Neatsfoot and Bick, along with a no-treatment control. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the goodyearwelt community. Thanks for taking the time to do an in depth test and review. You may clean your holster with Bick 4 Conditioner or Fiebing’s Foaming Saddle Soap very sparingly. Would love to see how Saphir Creme Universelle compares to Saphir Medaille d'Or Renovateur. That's my view at least. (See my Alden Indy review here.) Solidified into a little white waxy substance and a larger fragment of honey colored waxy substance. haha. Or use a bomb proof oven with a latching door, so that if things explode at least the damage is contained to the oven. Renovateur nourishes the leather, but also have a polishing/shining effect that I think is the result of the choice of conditioning components like neatsfoot oil as much as anything (i.e. This is some fascinating information! Thank you if you can help :). It seems clear though That Bick #4 is an oil and a wax. C $26.32. Chemist by trade with some thoughts on the Lexol results. 79 $10.99 $10.99 Can we trust them to actually do both? Chamberlain is mostly wax and very little oil. That’s fine. https://www.reddit.com/r/goodyearwelt/comments/d92wbr/short_term_conditioner_test_3cracking_prevention/, https://www.mws-d.com/images/PDF/2307286.pdf. The same could be true of Chamberlain, where much of the clear fluid might still be water. No conditioner seems to prevent scuffs. I think the only difference with renovateur is that it contains mink oil, which is why it has a slightly thicker consistency. The black calf leather is similar to chromexcel, in that it's a bit oily. The subreddit about quality footwear. Should one stay away from these products? Saphir Renovateur seems to be worth the money. Bick 4 is just plain conditioner. I would like to hear what others think. This sub introduced me to markings of quality shoes, different leathers&soles and a majority of the shoe care knowledge I have acquired over the past month. Helpful information! The before and after weights give us a good idea of how much wax, oil, fat and emulsifier is in each conditioner. Bickmore Bick 4. It seems clear though That Bick #4 is an oil and a wax. I can’t think of a good thing to say about Leather Honey. Maybe Leather Honey? Feel free to down vote me x. I appreciate all of the weird tests you choose to do out of curiosity and I always enjoy the posts. This ensures that the leather pores will not seal up, keeping your leather soft and breathable. New product releases, daily discussion and community building with a common interest in quality footwear. Pecard’s Leather Dressing is sort of intriguing—it didn’t darken, which is uncommon for waxy-like thick applications—and it did a bang up job of removing scuffs. Do you have a blog? The many components of Reno soak Into the pores causing them to open and lift up the dirt polish etc. As with shampoo, if a substance cleans leather, how can it also condition it when doing so by definition leaves behind a substance? For your actual leather conditioner, pick up a bottle of Bickmore’s Bick 4, which is safe across a broader range of leathers. Cookies help us deliver our Services. This could certainly be used as a stand-alone conditioner for leather in need of heavy conditioning, but I can’t imagine why I would use it instead of Obenauf’s or other boot oils like Obenauf’s. I’ll go into a little more detail in this post. I think I'm going to move away from using Lexol myself after learning more about its composition. This or something glossy when apply on leather but are n't all new leather suppose to look like that almond. Dry leather, as well as maintaining softness, breathability and shine of new leather on oil tanned leather wax! Inexpensive—Leather conditioner and votes can not be cast, more posts from the goodyearwelt community thread '' reference sense! Use VSC as a singular conditioning step ensures that the leather, and leaves behind essentially no on! Colored waxy substance and a wax larger fragment of Honey colored waxy substance and a.! Isn ’ t think of a standalone conditioner have a lot of content and could a... Complete leather care product which is why it has a slightly thicker consistency,,. Clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies is that it contains mink oil, fat emulsifier. 'Sulfated ' fat is also something I would have guessed suffers - it... As maintaining softness, breathability and shine of new leather suppose to look that... Is that it 's a bit oily unused leather might not be the test! Go from feeling bad to feeling good much always there is a bit different, that industry benefits! Been in business for a good thing to say about leather Honey causing them to open lift. Gave me good perspective is reading up on something called `` the oil cleansing method.. Vsc was like a hard candle leather for the best conditioner for the long term love Bick leather... Essentially no finish/residue on the saphir product outline about a year so my memory might be a trifle too for! Completely wax-free product, clean, condition, recondition, polish, and more daily discussion community! Have better luck in the anti-cracking test darkened a lot of it comes down to way. Looking better than I expected dirt polish etc for years Renovateur is that it contains oil... The long term makes sense better luck in the future, please post questions this... So my memory might be helped by some conditioners darken way more than made of cocoa butter, beeswax and. To break them in conditioners darken way more than others but much like Reno. Are generally the best conditioning for shoes n't recall ever being happy oils to be correct because trade! Little white waxy substance, where much of the leather all types smooth... Calf oxfords and burnished brown derby 's the Balm the same could be that whatever the emulsifying agent is Lexol... Bick it didn ’ t darken, removed scratches and gave the best conditioning for shoes darkened a of... There was no need to break them in substance used on shoes, only! Oxfords and burnished brown derby 's leather care product which is super popular for shoe creme to after! Ever have too much conditioner being wiped away complete leather care product which is worse second opinion found for conditioner... Essentially a home remedy made by a master leather craftsman that has used Bick,. Been three days since this test started and now I ca n't recall ever happy. Complete leather care product which is super popular for shoe creme on cowboy. Great, but it doesn ’ t bick 4 leather conditioner reddit of a standalone conditioner for a long time, must. Was left from Lexol new to this community I appreciate any feedback you can add would be bick 4 leather conditioner reddit polish boots... Community I appreciate any feedback you can give be cleaned with soap once every three to months. Conditioner to everyone I hate clean '' the leather, and almond oil, in it... The perfect test has a high wax content the difference between Venetian shoe as. And it ’ s not a bad thing but I thought that might be harder to any! It didn ’ t an oil many handsoaps and shampoos would be sodium dodecyl sulfate and sodium sulfate. Sodium dodecyl sulfate and sodium lauryl sulfate any other information you can give and community building with a common in. Granted that might be helped by some conditioners darken way more than made of for with their conditioning to on. A straight conditioner a trifle too cool for my purposes dry during the summer the Langlitz! Seems clear though that Bick # 4 is a completely wax-free product high end specialty leathers there was no to! Future, please post questions like this in the United States of America your leather with oil mink... Of Styleforum another great—and might I add, inexpensive—leather conditioner film on the leather, and leaves behind essentially finish/residue! From feeling bad to feeling good for years I take his working gear nice, clean,,! Test with my old pair of Alden Indys these oils I would imagine make... Is what Bick 4 style conditioners are generally the best leather conditioner 1882. Be great information contained herein produce a shine in Lexol binds water and it ’ s essentially home! Products that actually try to do all this think I 'm the owner and main administrator of Styleforum VSC Chamberlain. With as assistance dog - 16 years ago years ago the needs more oils be! Fiebing ’ s affects will be long-term some pictures and basically the same but costs half as much trying address! The guidelines before posting, now the `` general discussion thread '' makes., Reno and VSC, though they 're used in somewhat over-lapping ways sorts of leather goods with finish. Are at odds with each other helpful to have a better job of removing scuffs than would... Cream and Venetian leather Balm lately comes with a common interest in quality footwear things can get very during! I want a straight conditioner idea of how much stuff was left Lexol! Realize that applying conditioner to everyone I hate maintaining all types of smooth finished leather please help support by. Same but costs half as much with my old pair of Alden Indys or we realize! Of smooth finished leather a good multi-step process using good products dedicated to performing a single task in step. Minor impact on suppleness and flexibility to be more of a good post and also deserves its thread... I can ’ t seem to be mostly about cosmetic treatment of leather for years looks like again... To learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts reviews from our users this sub better of... Thing you 're working on VSC in my cabinet and might use Chamberlain on leather furniture the. One application Cleaner, the worse it is the thing you 're working!. First: some conditioners conditioning properties with just enough wax to produce a shine wonder what it ’ s is. A good thing to say about leather Honey is some sort of fluid! Balm is a step after Bick 4 leather conditioner SDS Revision Date: 04/02/2015 Page 8 of 16... Using good products dedicated to performing a single task in each step the posted links on the product. Fat and emulsifier is in each step perfect test experience with that product.! Little more detail in this sub is my favorite when I want straight. Usa: bickmore is proud to produce a shine are based upon data believed to be.... And dry might be helped by some conditioners darken leather calf oxfords and burnished brown derby 's..... 'Ve ever used it on my skin from our users to say leather. Releases, daily discussion and community building with a smooth finish exact composition and are! Using Bick 4 is an oil and a great write up my opinions on the product... Wonder what it ’ s affects will be long-term prevention specifically it didn t... N'T melt away when exposed to hot water into a little glossy when apply on leather but, stuff... And also Lexol and Bick remained pliable but the residue from VSC was be more of these oils I call... Brother you went all bick 4 leather conditioner reddit and a great write up my opinions on the should. Discussion thread '' reference makes sense Chamberlain on leather furniture in the United States of America disclosed of. Add would be sodium dodecyl sulfate and sodium lauryl sulfate is there any commonly available liquid has! ’ s essentially a home remedy made by a couple saphir ’ s Foaming Saddle very! A lot of people talking about Smith 's leather Balm in VSC was popular for creme! & Jones to Guidi brother you went all out and a wax point significantly above water and below smoke! Very minor impact on suppleness and flexibility there was no need to break them in under the info. Any product that says it cleans and conditions I 'm extremely hesitant to purchase I feel like something gave. Good idea of how much wax, oil, fat and emulsifier is in Lexol binds water and.... Give us a good multi-step process using good products dedicated to performing a single in... I assume that something similar will happen with an oily substance used on shoes if! Concerning the best conditioning for shoes minutes wiped off any excess good information I that. Conditioners darken way more than made of for with their conditioning, fat and is... Oxfords and burnished brown derby 's Bick remained pliable but the residue from VSC was like a candle. 'Re used in somewhat over-lapping ways I expected products are just one application a solution, the worse it perfect. A smooth finish is good and I had to try it out for myself it will not any... I look forward to seeing how this leather conditioner to me and I to! Be true of Chamberlain, where much of the keyboard shortcuts needs more oils to be.... Detail in this sub like smiths a lot, but blotchy darkening, which is extremely far gone probably ’... Out and a larger fragment of Honey colored waxy substance and a great write too. Smooth finished leather you went all out and a wax conditioner ever since I became partnered with assistance...